Part I: The Foundational Conflict: Islamic Finance vs. Conventional Cryptocurrencies
Section 1: Core Tenets of Sharia-Compliant Finance (Fiqh al-Muamalat)
The principles of Islamic finance, derived from Sharia (Islamic Law), constitute a comprehensive ethical and economic framework that governs all commercial transactions (Fiqh al-Muamalat). This framework is not a mere collection of prohibitive rules but an integrated system designed to achieve the higher objectives (maqasid) of Sharia, namely the promotion of justice ('adl), the prevention of exploitation, and the fostering of societal well-being (maslahah).1 At its core, Islamic finance seeks to ensure that financial activities are directly linked to the real economy, promoting productive enterprise and shared prosperity. Understanding these foundational tenets is a prerequisite for evaluating the permissibility of any new financial instrument, including cryptocurrency.
1.1 The Prohibition of Riba (Interest/Usury)
The absolute prohibition of riba is the cornerstone of the Islamic financial system.3
Riba, commonly translated as interest or usury, refers to any predetermined, guaranteed excess or premium on a loan, regardless of the rate. Islam considers the practice of lending money with interest payments to be fundamentally exploitative, as it guarantees a return to the lender based solely on the passage of time, without their participation in the risk of the underlying venture.3 This structure is seen as favoring the provider of capital at the expense of the borrower, thereby deepening the divide between the rich and the poor.6
The philosophical underpinning of this prohibition is the very definition of money in Islam. Money is not considered a commodity that can be bought, sold, or rented for a profit in and of itself. Instead, it is strictly viewed as a medium of exchange, a unit of account, and a store of value.6 To generate wealth from money alone—making money from money—is forbidden.7 Wealth, according to Sharia, can only be legitimately generated through productive economic activity, such as trade, manufacturing, and investment in tangible assets.7
In place of interest-based lending, Islamic finance champions models based on partnership and risk-sharing. The two primary structures are Mudarabah and Musharakah. Mudarabah is a profit-and-loss sharing partnership where one party, the financier (rab-ul mal), provides the capital, while the other party, the entrepreneur (mudarib), provides labor and expertise. Profits are shared according to a pre-agreed ratio, but any financial loss is borne solely by the financier, as the entrepreneur loses their time and effort.3
Musharakah is a joint venture where all partners contribute capital and share in both the profits and losses on a pro-rata basis.3 These structures ensure that capital is deployed in productive enterprises and that all parties have a stake in the outcome, aligning their interests and fostering a more equitable distribution of risk and reward.5
1.2 The Prohibition of Gharar (Excessive Uncertainty/Ambiguity)
Sharia law mandates clarity, transparency, and full disclosure in all contracts to prevent disputes and exploitation. This principle is encapsulated in the prohibition of gharar, which refers to excessive uncertainty, ambiguity, or risk in a contract.3 A contract containing significant
gharar is considered void because the lack of clarity regarding the subject matter, price, quantity, or delivery terms prevents the genuine mutual consent of the parties involved.6
Examples of transactions prohibited due to gharar include the sale of something the seller does not own or cannot deliver (e.g., fish not yet caught), the sale of an item whose characteristics are unknown, or contracts where the payment or delivery is contingent upon an unknown or random future event.10 This prohibition is the basis for the impermissibility of many conventional financial instruments like futures, options, and other derivatives, where the value and outcome are dependent on significant and uncertain future variables.3
It is crucial to recognize, however, that the prohibition of gharar is not absolute. Islamic jurisprudence distinguishes between minor, acceptable uncertainty (gharar yasir), which is an inherent part of any commercial activity, and major, excessive uncertainty (gharar fahish), which invalidates a contract.10 Scholars have established conditions for prohibited
gharar: it must be significant, exist in a commutative or exchange-based contract, and pertain to the core object of the contract.10 An element of uncertainty may be permissible in cases of public need or necessity (
maslahah), where the potential benefit outweighs the harm of the uncertainty.10 This nuanced understanding is central to the debate over cryptocurrency, as it requires a careful assessment of whether the inherent volatility of digital assets constitutes an acceptable business risk or a prohibited level of uncertainty.
1.3 The Prohibition of Maysir (Gambling/Speculation)
Closely related to gharar is the strict prohibition of maysir, which encompasses gambling and speculation.1
Maysir refers to the acquisition of wealth by chance at the expense of others, rather than through productive effort, trade, or legitimate investment.4 It is characterized in Islamic texts as a morally unclean activity that creates enmity, hatred, and distracts from piety.10
The defining feature of maysir is the creation of a zero-sum or negative-sum game, where one party's gain is directly contingent on another party's loss, and the outcome is dependent on a future, uncertain event. Islamic finance distinguishes between permissible risk-taking (mukhatarah), which is a necessary component of any investment in a real economic enterprise, and prohibited speculation, where the transaction itself has no underlying productive purpose.10
This principle is why financial practices such as short-selling, where an investor profits from a decline in an asset's price without ever owning it, are forbidden.3 The transaction is not intended to support a business or generate economic value but is purely a wager on price movement. Similarly, many derivative contracts are deemed impermissible as they are often used for speculative purposes rather than for hedging legitimate business risks.3 The application of this principle to cryptocurrency markets, which are often characterized by high levels of speculative trading, is a major point of contention among scholars.
1.4 The Requirement of Asset-Backing and Material Finality
A foundational principle that distinguishes Islamic finance from its conventional counterpart is the insistence on "material finality," which dictates that every financial transaction must be directly linked to a real, underlying economic transaction or a tangible asset.3 This ensures that finance remains firmly grounded in the real economy, serving as a facilitator of trade and production rather than a detached, self-perpetuating system.5 This principle acts as a natural safeguard against the creation of speculative bubbles and financial instruments that derive value from other financial instruments without any connection to a real asset or service.5
This requirement is most clearly illustrated in Islamic bonds, known as sukuk. Unlike a conventional bond, which is a certificate of debt obligating the issuer to pay interest, a sukuk is a certificate representing a share of ownership in a tangible asset, a project, or a specific investment venture.3 The return paid to
sukuk holders is not interest; it is a share of the profit generated by the underlying asset or enterprise.5 This structure ensures that the financing is tied to a productive purpose and that the investors are owners sharing in the performance of the asset, not merely lenders.12 This asset-backed nature is a crucial benchmark against which the intangible and often un-backed nature of many cryptocurrencies is measured.
1.5 The Principle of Risk and Profit Sharing
The principles of Islamic finance form a cohesive and interconnected system. The prohibition of riba is not a standalone rule but the catalyst for an entirely different economic paradigm built on risk and profit sharing. Instead of a debt-based relationship where risk is transferred to the borrower, Islamic finance mandates a partnership-based approach where financial institutions share risks and rewards with their clients.5 This symmetrical distribution of risk and return ensures that no single party benefits disproportionately from a transaction and fosters a more equitable and collaborative financial environment.3
This philosophy is operationalized through the aforementioned Mudarabah and Musharakah contracts, which are the primary modes of Islamic investment and financing.3 By becoming partners in an enterprise, Islamic financial institutions are incentivized to conduct thorough due diligence and support the ventures they finance, as their returns are directly tied to the success of the project.5 This contrasts sharply with the conventional model, where a bank's primary concern is the borrower's ability to repay the loan with interest, regardless of the venture's profitability. The principle of risk sharing encourages more responsible and prudent lending and investment practices, contributing to greater financial stability.5
1.6 Ethical Investment Mandates
Beyond the structural rules of transactions, Islamic finance incorporates a strong ethical dimension that governs the types of activities that can be financed or invested in. Investments in industries considered haram (forbidden) or harmful to society are strictly prohibited.3 This includes businesses involved in the production or sale of alcohol, pork, and non-halal food products; gambling and casinos; conventional interest-based financial services like banks and insurance companies; weapons manufacturing; and adult entertainment or pornography.5
This ethical screening process ensures that capital is directed towards productive and socially beneficial enterprises, aligning financial objectives with moral values.13 This aspect of Islamic finance has found common ground with the modern global trend of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) investing, as both frameworks seek to avoid investments that cause societal or environmental harm.5 The core objective is to promote the public benefit (
maslahah) and ensure that wealth is generated and utilized in a manner that is not only profitable but also just and ethical.1 This ethical layer provides another critical filter for assessing cryptocurrencies, particularly concerning their use in illicit activities and the governance of their underlying platforms.
Section 2: A Critical Assessment of Cryptocurrencies through the Lens of Sharia
The emergence of decentralized digital assets built on blockchain technology presents a profound challenge to traditional financial paradigms and, consequently, to the established principles of Islamic finance. The application of a legal framework developed over centuries to this novel technology has resulted in a significant and ongoing debate among Islamic legal scholars (fuqaha). There is no monolithic "Islamic view" on cryptocurrency; rather, there is a spectrum of opinions rooted in differing interpretations of how core Sharia principles apply to the unique characteristics of these digital assets.17 This section will critically assess the most prominent cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin, through the jurisprudential lens established in the previous section, synthesizing the arguments that lead to divergent rulings.
2.1 The Scholarly Divide: Halal vs. Haram
The global Muslim community has been met with a variety of conflicting legal rulings (fatawa) regarding the permissibility of engaging with cryptocurrencies. This has created a state of confusion and uncertainty for individuals and institutions seeking to navigate the digital economy while adhering to their faith.17
On one side of the debate are prominent scholars and religious bodies who have declared dealing in cryptocurrencies to be haram (forbidden). This group includes the Grand Mufti of Egypt, Shaykh Shawki Allam, and the Turkish Government's Directorate of Religious Affairs.20 Their arguments, which will be detailed below, center on the perceived excessive uncertainty, speculative nature, lack of intrinsic value, and potential for illicit use associated with assets like Bitcoin.21
On the other side, a number of scholars and advisory bodies have concluded that cryptocurrencies can be halal (permissible), often with important caveats and conditions. Proponents of this view include Mufti Muhammad Abu-Bakar and the Shariah Advisory Council of Malaysia's Securities Commission.21 Their reasoning often focuses on the technological neutrality of cryptocurrency, its potential as a medium of exchange, and the argument that social acceptance is sufficient to grant it the status of legitimate wealth (
mal).17
This sharp divide underscores that the issue is not simple. It reflects the inherent difficulty of applying classical legal concepts to a technology that is abstract, rapidly evolving, and lacks historical precedent in Islamic jurisprudence. A nuanced, context-sensitive approach is therefore necessary, one that moves beyond a blanket ruling for all cryptocurrencies and instead evaluates each digital asset and its use case on its own merits.17
2.2 The Problem of Gharar (Excessive Uncertainty)
The most significant and frequently cited objection to cryptocurrencies from a Sharia perspective is the presence of excessive gharar.1 This argument has several interconnected facets:
First, the extreme price volatility of most major cryptocurrencies is seen as a primary source of gharar. Scholars arguing for prohibition point to the dramatic and unpredictable price fluctuations as a clear violation of the principle of certainty in contracts.17 When the value of a currency can change drastically within hours or even minutes, it introduces a level of uncertainty that can lead to significant, unforeseen losses and disputes, undermining the stability and fairness that Sharia seeks to preserve in transactions.21
Second, this volatility is deeply linked to the debate over the "intrinsic value" of cryptocurrencies. Opponents, such as Shaykh Haitham al-Haddad, argue that assets like Bitcoin are not permissible because they are not based on any real, underlying value.21 They are seen as purely digital constructs, "imaginary numbers" whose value is derived solely from speculation, not from any tangible asset or productive capacity.19 This lack of an anchor in the real economy makes their valuation inherently uncertain and unstable.
Third, the absence of a central authority, such as a government or central bank, to back the currency and regulate its supply is a major concern.19 While fiat currencies are also not backed by a physical commodity like gold since the end of the Bretton-Woods system, they are backed by the full faith and credit of a sovereign state, which provides a measure of stability and legal authority.21 Cryptocurrencies, by design, lack this backing, which contributes to their volatility and the uncertainty surrounding their long-term viability.
Conversely, scholars who find cryptocurrencies permissible counter these arguments by redefining the concept of value. They contend that Sharia does not strictly require a currency to have intrinsic value (like gold or silver). Rather, what is essential is its social acceptance ('urf) and utility as a medium of exchange.21 From this perspective, if a community of users agrees to accept a digital asset as a form of payment and it can be used in transactions, it qualifies as legitimate wealth (
mal mutaqawwam).17 They argue that its value, while volatile, is determined by supply and demand in a market, similar to other commodities. However, even these scholars often add a prudential note, warning that excessive volatility driven by irrational behavior could render trading in such assets questionable.21
2.3 The Problem of Maysir (Speculation)
The second major objection is that the dominant use case for many cryptocurrencies is not as a medium of exchange for goods and services, but as a vehicle for speculation, which is tantamount to gambling (maysir).1 The market behavior surrounding many digital assets, characterized by individuals buying and selling in the hope of making quick profits from price fluctuations, is seen as a direct violation of the prohibition against
maysir.1
The argument is that this activity does not represent a genuine investment in a productive enterprise. Instead, it mirrors a zero-sum game where one person's gains come directly from another's losses, driven by hope and greed rather than economic fundamentals.10 The focus on profiting from the simple difference between buying and selling currencies, without any underlying trade of goods or services, is considered by some scholars to be a form of
riba or, at the very least, a practice that encourages the unproductive and morally hazardous behavior associated with gambling.2 This speculative frenzy, often fueled by retail investors with a poor understanding of the technology, is seen as a source of market instability and a deviation from the Sharia's emphasis on generating wealth through legitimate, value-creating activities.5
2.4 The Question of Riba in DeFi
While the simple act of buying and holding a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin may not involve riba, the rapid expansion of the Decentralized Finance (DeFi) ecosystem has introduced new and significant Sharia compliance challenges. Many DeFi protocols are built around lending and borrowing platforms that explicitly offer users a return for depositing or "staking" their assets.17
These platforms often function in a manner analogous to conventional interest-based banking. A user deposits their cryptocurrency into a lending pool and, in return, receives a predetermined or variable yield. This yield, regardless of what it is called ("staking rewards," "yield farming," etc.), functions as interest on a loan. From a Sharia perspective, this is a clear instance of riba and is therefore strictly prohibited.3
It is important to distinguish this from other forms of staking. For instance, in a Proof-of-Stake (PoS) network, staking involves locking up tokens to help secure the network and validate transactions. The rewards received in this context can be viewed as a fee for providing a service to the network, which may be permissible.25 However, the line between permissible service fees and impermissible interest can be technically complex and requires careful scrutiny of the specific mechanics of each protocol. The proliferation of
riba-based models within the DeFi space is a major concern for Islamic scholars and a significant barrier to Muslim participation in this sector of the crypto economy.
2.5 Other Concerns: Illicit Use and Lack of Regulation
Finally, scholars have raised broader ethical concerns related to the maqasid al-Shariah, or the higher objectives of Islamic law, which include the protection of wealth and the prevention of societal harm (mafsadah). The pseudo-anonymous and decentralized nature of many cryptocurrencies has made them a favored tool for illicit activities, including money laundering, terrorist financing, and the purchase of illegal goods and services.20 While the technology itself is neutral, its widespread use for such nefarious purposes is a significant factor in the ethical calculus of its permissibility.20
Furthermore, the general lack of a robust regulatory framework and consumer protection mechanisms is a major point of concern.21 In the event of fraud, theft, or the loss of a private key, users often have no legal recourse to recover their funds, which is a stark contrast to the regulated traditional banking system.21 This lack of oversight and protection for users' wealth runs contrary to the Sharia's emphasis on safeguarding property and ensuring fairness and security in financial dealings.
The analysis of these issues reveals a critical distinction. The core of the scholarly debate is not an objection to the underlying blockchain technology itself. In fact, many scholars and institutions recognize the potential of blockchain to enhance transparency and efficiency, which are values that align well with Islamic finance.1 The objections are aimed squarely at the
economic characteristics and dominant use cases of the specific assets built upon this technology. The problems of volatility, speculation, lack of intrinsic value, and illicit use are not inherent flaws of blockchain; they are features of the design and market environment of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin. This logical progression leads to a powerful conclusion: if the economic design were to be fundamentally altered—by intentionally engineering for stability, utility, and value-backing—the entire Sharia analysis could be transformed. The path to creating a halal cryptocurrency, therefore, lies not in abandoning the technology, but in re-engineering its economic and ethical architecture from the ground up.
Part II: The Blueprint for a Halal Digital Asset
Moving from a critical analysis of existing systems to a constructive framework, this section outlines the essential architectural, governance, and ethical principles required to design a digital asset that is fundamentally compliant with the tenets of Sharia law. The objective is not to create a superficial "Islamic" version of a conventional cryptocurrency, but to engineer a new class of digital asset that embeds the core principles of Islamic finance at the protocol level.
Section 3: Architectural Principles for a Sharia-Compliant Cryptocurrency
A truly Sharia-compliant digital asset requires a foundational architecture that directly addresses the core objections of gharar, maysir, and the lack of intrinsic value. This involves a deliberate shift from creating a purely speculative instrument to building a robust digital representation of real economic value.
3.1 Foundational Requirement: Asset-Backing and Intrinsic Value
The most robust and direct method to counter the problems of gharar (excessive uncertainty) and the lack of intrinsic value is to ensure that the digital asset is fully backed by a portfolio of tangible, permissible (halal) assets.1 This approach grounds the cryptocurrency in the real economy, a core requirement of Islamic finance, and provides a clear and defensible basis for its valuation.
A proposed model for such an asset would function as a digital sukuk. The cryptocurrency would be a token that represents a direct, divisible, and legally enforceable share of ownership in a transparently managed reserve of real assets.12 This reserve could be composed of a variety of Sharia-compliant assets, such as:
Precious Metals: Gold and silver, which have historically been recognized as stable stores of value in Islamic tradition.21
Real Estate: Ownership in income-generating properties, provided they are used for halal purposes.11
Sharia-Compliant Equities: Shares in publicly traded companies that have passed both qualitative (business activity) and quantitative (financial ratio) screens to ensure they are not involved in prohibited industries and do not have excessive debt or interest-based income.3
Islamic Bonds (Sukuk): Investments in existing Sharia-compliant bonds that represent ownership in underlying assets or projects.11
Under this model, each token would have a floor price, or a Net Asset Value (NAV), determined by the total value of the assets in the reserve divided by the number of tokens in circulation. This directly refutes the argument that the asset is an "imaginary number" with no real value.19 To ensure transparency and trust, the project would be required to conduct regular, independent audits of the asset reserves, with the results published immutably on the blockchain for all token holders to verify. This structure transforms the token from a speculative currency into a digital title deed, fundamentally altering its Sharia compliance profile.
3.2 Embedding Utility and Purpose (Manfa'ah)
Beyond being a store of value, a halal digital asset must be designed with a clear and productive purpose (manfa'ah) to justify its existence and circulation.1 A key argument for the permissibility of any currency is its utility and social acceptance as a medium of exchange.17 Therefore, a Sharia-compliant cryptocurrency should be more than just a tradable asset; it should be an integral part of a functioning,
halal economic ecosystem.
The proposed model would involve designing the token as a utility token, granting the holder access to specific goods or services within a defined ecosystem. This links the token's value not only to its backing assets but also to the real economic activity of its platform. Examples of such ecosystems include:
Halal E-commerce: The token could be the exclusive medium of payment on a platform dedicated to the sale of halal goods and services.
Transparent Supply Chains: The token could be used to pay for transaction fees on a blockchain that tracks the provenance of halal products, from farm to table.
Sharia-Compliant Smart Contracts: The token could be the required asset for executing automated, Sharia-compliant financial contracts, such as those for leasing or profit-sharing.
By embedding genuine utility, the token acquires a value based on the demand for the services it enables. This creates a virtuous cycle: as the ecosystem grows and provides more value, the demand for the token increases, supporting its price independently of pure market speculation.
3.3 Protocol-Level Mitigation of Volatility and Speculation
While asset-backing provides a crucial value floor, additional mechanisms can be engineered at the protocol level to further stabilize the asset's value and discourage the kind of short-term speculative trading that is considered maysir.12 The goal is not to eliminate all risk, but to curb excessive, unproductive volatility that creates
gharar.17
One proposed model is the implementation of a dynamic transaction fee, sometimes known as a "friction" fee. This fee could be algorithmically designed to be very low for transactions related to the ecosystem's utility (e.g., buying a product) or for long-term holders, but to increase significantly for high-frequency trading. For instance, a smart contract could impose a higher fee on tokens that are sold within a short period (e.g., 30 days) of being acquired. This would make rapid day-trading less profitable and encourage a longer-term investment horizon, aligning with the Islamic principle of discouraging short-term speculation.12
Furthermore, the platform's smart contracts should be designed to facilitate stable, trade-based Islamic financing modes like Ijarah (leasing) and Istisna (manufacturing finance).3 By providing tools for real economic financing, the platform can channel capital towards productive uses, creating an environment that is inherently less speculative than one focused solely on currency trading.
3.4 Creating Riba-Free Financial Instruments via Smart Contracts
One of the most powerful applications of blockchain technology in this context is its ability to automate and enforce complex, Sharia-compliant financial agreements with perfect transparency. This allows for the creation of truly riba-free DeFi instruments that are more robustly compliant than their traditional counterparts. The reliance in conventional Islamic finance on extensive legal paperwork and human oversight to ensure adherence to profit-and-loss sharing terms can be replaced by the immutable logic of a smart contract. This use of technology can solve, rather than create, problems of trust and ambiguity.
Proposed models for these smart contracts include:
Mudarabah Smart Contract: Investors could pool their asset-backed tokens into a decentralized venture capital fund. The fund manager (the mudarib) would invest this capital in approved, halal startups. The smart contract would be coded with the pre-agreed profit-sharing ratio. It would automatically and transparently distribute profits to the investors and the manager only if and when the venture becomes profitable. All financial losses would be automatically borne by the capital-providing investors, perfectly executing the risk-sharing terms of a Mudarabah agreement.
Musharakah Smart Contract: Multiple parties could contribute capital to a joint venture, such as the development of a real estate property. The smart contract would act as a digital partnership agreement, immutably recording the ownership stake of each partner. It would then automatically distribute all revenues and expenses according to these stakes, ensuring a fair and proportional sharing of both profits and losses as required by a Musharakah contract.
Halal Staking and Liquidity Pools: The concept of "staking" would be fundamentally redefined. Instead of lending tokens to a pool to earn interest, users would "stake" their tokens in productive ventures, such as the Mudarabah fund described above. Alternatively, they could provide liquidity to trading pairs on a decentralized exchange (e.g., pairing the asset-backed token with another asset). In this case, their return would not be a predetermined interest rate, but a direct share of the actual transaction fees generated by that trading pair. This model ensures that returns are generated from real economic activity (trading fees) and that providers share in the risk and reward of the venture, in perfect alignment with Islamic principles.28
This approach represents a paradigm shift. Instead of viewing cryptocurrency as a digital version of money, it reframes it as a digital asset-ownership system. By designing the token from its inception as a digital representation of ownership in real, productive assets—akin to a sukuk—the contentious debate over whether it qualifies as "money" is effectively sidestepped.2 The asset is no longer an abstract value but a transparent, auditable, and transferable digital title deed, making the path to Sharia compliance far clearer and more defensible.
Section 4: Governance, Ethics, and Social Impact
Technical and economic architecture alone are insufficient to guarantee Sharia compliance. A truly halal digital asset must be embedded within a robust framework of governance, ethical oversight, and a commitment to positive social impact. This non-technical layer is critical for ensuring long-term legitimacy, trust, and alignment with the higher objectives (maqasid) of Islamic law.
4.1 The Central Role of a Sharia Supervisory Board
A non-negotiable requirement for any entity claiming to be an Islamic financial institution is the establishment of an independent Sharia Supervisory Board.4 This principle applies with equal, if not greater, force to a cryptocurrency project. The credibility and legitimacy of the entire project hinge on the reputation, expertise, and independence of this board.
The proposed model requires that a Sharia Supervisory Board be established from the very inception of the project, before any technical development begins. This board must be composed of internationally recognized scholars who possess dual expertise: a deep, classical training in Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh al-muamalat) and a sophisticated understanding of modern finance and technology. Their role cannot be merely ceremonial or advisory; they must be granted genuine authority within the project's governance structure. The board's key responsibilities must include:
Initial Approval: Reviewing and issuing a formal fatwa approving the project's whitepaper, its economic model, the composition of its asset reserves, and its governance charter.
Continuous Auditing: Conducting regular (e.g., quarterly) audits of the project's operations. This includes verifying the existence and valuation of the underlying asset reserves and scrutinizing the logic of the smart contracts to ensure they function as intended and do not violate Sharia principles.
Binding Rulings: Possessing the authority to issue binding rulings on any new features, financial products, or partnerships proposed for the platform.
Public Reporting: Publishing their audit findings and legal rulings in a transparent manner for the entire community of token holders.
This structure creates a necessary check and balance, ensuring that the project remains compliant throughout its lifecycle, not just at its launch.
4.2 Community Governance: The Shura DAO Model
The decentralized nature of blockchain technology aligns well with the Islamic principle of Shura, or mutual consultation, in governance.29 A Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO) can serve as a powerful tool for implementing this principle, giving the community of token holders a direct voice in the project's operational decisions.
In the proposed Shura DAO model, token holders would be granted voting rights on matters such as the selection of asset managers for the reserve portfolio, proposals for new ecosystem projects, and the allocation of a community development fund. However, the crypto ethos of absolute, leaderless decentralization is in direct tension with the Islamic legal requirement for authoritative scholarly oversight. Islamic law (Sharia) is not a static set of rules that can be perfectly encoded; it requires ongoing interpretation (ijtihad) by qualified scholars. A purely decentralized DAO could, in theory, vote to implement a feature that violates Sharia principles, such as a riba-based lending protocol, thereby rendering the entire system haram.
To resolve this tension, a hybrid governance model is necessary. The Shura DAO would operate within a "constitutional" framework established and ratified by the Sharia Supervisory Board. The community would have decentralized control over operational matters, but the Sharia Board would retain ultimate authority on matters of religious compliance, holding a "constitutional veto" over any proposal that contravenes the established Sharia framework. This model balances the participatory benefits of decentralization with the essential requirement for authoritative religious guidance, creating a system that is not fully trustless, but "trust-minimized" and reliant on the trusted authority of the Sharia Board.
4.3 Integrated Zakat and Social Impact (Maslahah)
A financial instrument that is merely "permissible" falls short of the higher objectives of Islamic finance, which aim to promote social welfare (maslahah) and the circulation of wealth for the benefit of the entire community.1 A truly Islamic digital asset should be designed not just to preserve and grow wealth for its holders, but to function as an active instrument of Islamic social finance. This can be achieved by integrating the pillar of
Zakat (obligatory annual charity) directly into the platform's architecture.
The current ambiguity surrounding the calculation and payment of zakat on cryptocurrencies is a significant challenge for Muslim investors.17 An asset-backed, Sharia-compliant platform is uniquely positioned to solve this problem. The proposed model would include:
Automated Zakat Calculation: The platform's native wallet could feature a tool that automatically calculates a user's zakat liability. Since the token's value is tied to a transparently audited portfolio of real assets, the valuation (nisab threshold) is clear and defensible, removing the uncertainty that plagues conventional cryptocurrencies.17
Transparent On-Chain Distribution: Users could opt-in to pay their zakat directly from their wallet via a smart contract. This contract could distribute the funds to a list of pre-vetted, certified charitable organizations whose own wallet addresses are publicly known. This would create an unprecedented level of transparency and auditability in charitable giving, allowing donors to see exactly where their contributions are going.
Digital Waqf (Endowment): To further align the project's success with societal benefit, a small percentage of every transaction fee could be automatically channeled into a digital waqf, or charitable endowment.17 This
waqf, managed by the DAO under the supervision of the Sharia Board, would create a perpetual fund for financing social projects such as education, healthcare, and sustainable development.
By embedding these features at the protocol level, the cryptocurrency is transformed. It becomes more than just a halal investment; it becomes an active tool for fulfilling religious obligations and achieving the core Islamic economic goal of social justice. This elevates the project from being merely acceptable to being ethically and religiously desirable.
Part III: Case Studies and Practical Implementation
To bridge the gap between theory and practice, this final part provides a critical analysis of existing projects that have attempted to create Sharia-compliant cryptocurrencies. These projects are evaluated against the comprehensive blueprint developed in Part II. This comparative analysis illuminates the common pitfalls and potential strengths of current approaches, culminating in a practical roadmap for any individual or group seeking to successfully implement a truly halal digital asset.
Section 5: Critical Analysis of Existing "Islamic" Cryptocurrency Projects
Several projects have emerged with the explicit goal of serving the Muslim market. By scrutinizing their claims, technology, and governance structures against the established Sharia-compliance framework, it is possible to discern their respective strengths and weaknesses. This analysis focuses on three prominent examples representing different approaches: a governance-first model, an ecosystem-first model, and an asset-first model.
5.1 Case Study: Islamic Coin (ISLM) / HAQQ Network
Islamic Coin (ISLM) is the native currency of the HAQQ ("Truth") blockchain, a project that has garnered significant attention due to its high-profile Sharia governance.27
Claims and Features: The project's primary claim to compliance rests on its establishment of a prestigious Sharia Board led by Sheikh Dr. Nizam Mohammed Saleh Yaquby, a globally recognized authority in Islamic finance whose advisory roles have included top-tier institutions like HSBC, Barclays, and Standard Chartered.32 This board has issued a
fatwa approving the project's structure.35 Technologically, it operates on a Proof-of-Stake blockchain and features a "Sharia Oracle," an on-chain mechanism designed to whitelist approved smart contracts and dApps for use within its native wallet, effectively creating a curated,
halal ecosystem.37 A key feature is the "Evergreen DAO," a non-profit endowment that automatically receives 10% of each newly minted ISLM, creating a perpetual fund for community and charitable projects.27 Crucially, ISLM is not explicitly backed by tangible assets; its whitepaper states that its value is determined by the market.27Analysis against the Blueprint:
Asset-Backing: ISLM fails to meet the foundational criterion of asset-backing. Its value is not tethered to a real-world portfolio, leaving it fully exposed to market sentiment and speculation. This makes it inherently susceptible to the same extreme volatility that is the primary source of gharar in conventional cryptocurrencies, a fact confirmed by its historical price performance.40
Governance: This is the project's greatest strength and a direct alignment with the blueprint. The establishment of a credible, authoritative, and independent Sharia Board is exemplary and provides a strong foundation of religious legitimacy. The Sharia Oracle is an innovative technological implementation of the board's oversight role.
Social Impact: The Evergreen DAO is a powerful and well-designed feature that directly corresponds to the blueprint's recommendation for an integrated waqf-like structure, ensuring that the project's growth contributes to the community's welfare.
Verdict: Islamic Coin represents a "governance-first" approach. It has established a gold standard for Sharia oversight in the crypto space. However, its fundamental failure to address the core issue of asset-backing and intrinsic value leaves it vulnerable to the critical scholarly objections regarding gharar and maysir.
5.2 Case Study: ISLAMICOIN (ISLAMI)
ISLAMICOIN is a token project that aims to build a comprehensive digital ecosystem for Muslims, encompassing a wide range of services.42
Claims and Features: Launched initially on the Polygon blockchain, ISLAMICOIN's vision is to create its own "ISLAMIBLOCKCHAIN" that will power a suite of applications, including ISLAMIwallet, ISLAMImall (e-commerce), ISLAMIgame, and ISLAMItravel.42 Its claim to Sharia compliance is based on its focus on
halal industries and a unique charity mechanism where 2.5% of every transaction's value is automatically paid by the smart contract to a charity treasury called "Bayt Al-Mal".43Analysis against the Blueprint:
Asset-Backing: The project provides no evidence of being backed by any tangible assets. Its value is purely determined by market forces and speculation, which is reflected in its extreme price volatility and very low market capitalization.43
Governance: The project lacks a clearly defined and high-profile Sharia Supervisory Board comparable to that of Islamic Coin. It mentions following recommendations from an entity called the "Office of Crypto Halal," but the international standing, expertise, and independence of this body are not as well-established as those of the scholars on ISLM's board.45
Utility: The project's ambition to build a utility-driven ecosystem aligns with the blueprint's principle of embedding manfa'ah. However, these platforms are largely aspirational, and the token's value is not yet supported by a widely adopted and functioning ecosystem.
Verdict: ISLAMICOIN represents an "ecosystem-first" approach. While its goal of creating a utility-driven platform is sound in principle, it suffers from fundamental weaknesses in the two most critical areas: it lacks both the asset-backing necessary to mitigate gharar and the high-authority Sharia governance required for true legitimacy.
5.3 Case Study: OneGram (OGC)
OneGram was one of the earliest and most conceptually straightforward attempts to create a Sharia-compliant cryptocurrency by directly linking it to a physical asset.46
Claims and Features: The core concept of OneGram was that each OGC token would be backed by a minimum of one gram of physical gold, stored in a secure, audited vault.46 This direct, one-to-one backing was designed to provide intrinsic value and a stable floor price, thus directly addressing the problem of
gharar. The project also featured a novel mechanism where a portion of transaction fees would be reinvested to purchase more gold for the reserve, theoretically increasing the amount of gold backing each coin over time.47Analysis against the Blueprint:
Asset-Backing: OneGram's model is a perfect conceptual alignment with the blueprint's foundational requirement of asset-backing. By linking the digital token to physical gold—an asset with deep historical and religious significance in Islamic finance—it provides the most robust possible solution to the problem of intrinsic value.
Mitigation of Gharar and Maysir: By tying the token's value to the spot price of gold, the model inherently minimizes the potential for the kind of wild, un-anchored speculation seen in other cryptocurrencies.46 It transforms the asset from a speculative bet into a digital representation of a stable commodity.
Governance: The project's whitepaper discusses adherence to the Maqasid al-Shariah and compliance with the Sharia Gold Standard issued by the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI).46 However, the long-term structure and public profile of its specific Sharia board and auditing processes were less prominent than those of a project like Islamic Coin.
Verdict: OneGram represents an "asset-first" approach. Conceptually, its model is the strongest in addressing the primary scholarly objections related to gharar, maysir, and value. It is a direct and elegant application of the sukuk principle to the digital asset space. The ultimate viability of such a model depends entirely on the operational execution, specifically the transparency, security, and unimpeachable integrity of its gold reserve auditing process.
Table 5.1: Comparative Analysis of Sharia-Compliant Cryptocurrency Projects
Section 6: A Concluding Roadmap for Implementation
Synthesizing the foundational principles of Islamic finance, the critique of conventional cryptocurrencies, and the analysis of existing projects, this report concludes with a practical, sequential roadmap for creating a digital asset that is not only defensibly Sharia-compliant but also robust, transparent, and ethically grounded.
Step 1: Establish the Jurisprudential Foundation
The first and most critical step is to establish the project's religious and ethical authority. Before any code is written or capital is raised, an independent, reputable, and authoritative Sharia Supervisory Board must be formally engaged. The selection of scholars with recognized expertise in both classical jurisprudence and modern finance is paramount, as the credibility of the entire project will be built upon their integrity and rulings. This board must be empowered with genuine oversight, not merely an advisory role.Step 2: Define the Economic Model - The Asset-First Approach
The analysis demonstrates that the most effective way to address the core scholarly objections of gharar and the lack of intrinsic value is through full asset-backing. Therefore, the next step is to define the economic model based on an "asset-first" principle, similar to the OneGram concept. A specific portfolio of tangible, halal assets (e.g., gold, sukuk, Sharia-compliant real estate) must be selected to form the reserve. A clear legal structure must be established to ensure that each token represents a true, enforceable ownership share in this reserve.Step 3: Draft the Sharia-Compliant Whitepaper
With the Sharia Board in place and the economic model defined, a comprehensive whitepaper must be drafted. This document is the project's constitution. It must transparently detail every aspect of the project, including the composition and management of the asset portfolio, the legal framework of token ownership, the mechanisms for independent and regular auditing of the reserves, the hybrid governance model (defining the roles of the Sharia Board and the Shura DAO), and the integrated social impact features like automated zakat and the digital waqf. This whitepaper must then be formally reviewed, amended if necessary, and ultimately approved and endorsed with a public fatwa from the Sharia Board.Step 4: Design the Technical Architecture
Only after the jurisprudential and economic foundations are solidified should technical development begin. The blockchain protocol and its associated smart contracts must be meticulously designed to be a direct reflection of the approved whitepaper. The code must immutably enforce the rules of profit-sharing in any investment vehicles, ensure the transparent and automated distribution of zakat and waqf contributions, and facilitate the hybrid governance model. Security and transparency should be the guiding principles of the technical architecture.Step 5: Ensure Continuous Compliance and Auditing
The launch of the digital asset is the beginning, not the end, of the compliance journey. A rigorous and continuous process of oversight must be implemented. This includes a publicly available schedule of regular, independent audits of both the financial reserves (conducted by a reputable accounting firm) and the smart contract code (conducted by a top-tier blockchain security firm). The Sharia Supervisory Board must remain actively engaged, reviewing and approving all future protocol upgrades, new financial products, and strategic partnerships. Their findings, approvals, and any new rulings must be published regularly to the community to maintain the trust and legitimacy that are the ultimate assets of any Sharia-compliant enterprise.
Works cited
Islamic Cryptocurrency: A Shariah Principles' Perspective Study on Current Financial Development - SUKUK: INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF BANKING, FINANCE, MANAGEMENT AND BUSINESS, accessed September 1, 2025, https://sukukjournal.org.uk/index.php/sukuk/article/download/50/56
(PDF) Cryptocurrencies: A Critical Analysis from the perspective of ..., accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/365004481_Cryptocurrencies_A_Critical_Analysis_from_the_perspective_of_Islamic_Law
Principles and Types of Islamic Finance, accessed September 1, 2025, https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/career-map/sell-side/capital-markets/islamic-finance/
Islamic banking and finance - Wikipedia, accessed September 1, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_banking_and_finance
Islamic Finance and Its Role in Ethical Banking - FinTech Weekly, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.fintechweekly.com/magazine/articles/islamic-finance-and-ethical-banking
Islamic Banking: Definition, History, and Example - Investopedia, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/islamicbanking.asp
Guide to Islamic finance | Islamic banking | Sharia compliant & ethical - Al Rayan Bank, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.alrayanbank.co.uk/guide-islamic-finance
Halal Investing 101: A Beginner's Guide to Shariah-Compliant Investments - Zoya Blog, accessed September 1, 2025, https://blog.zoya.finance/halal-investing-101/
Islamic finance - Pinsent Masons, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.pinsentmasons.com/out-law/guides/islamic-finance
(PDF) Understanding Riba and Gharar in Islamic Finance - ResearchGate, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/376232337_Understanding_Riba_and_Gharar_in_Islamic_Finance
Understanding Shariah-Compliant Investments - Holborn Assets Saudi Arabia, accessed September 1, 2025, https://holbornassets.sa/blog/understanding-shariah-compliant-investments/
Halal Investing - Saturna Capital, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.saturna.com/insights/investor-education/halal-investing
What is Islamic halal investment and why is it on the rise? | Business and Economy News | Al Jazeera, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/3/28/what-is-islamic-and-halal-investment-is-it-on-the-rise
www.investopedia.com, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/islamicbanking.asp#:~:text=Islamic%20banking%20is%20a%20financial,and%20transparency%20in%20financial%20dealings.
What Is Halal Investing? - NerdWallet, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/investing/halal-investing
Islamicly Shariah Screening Criteria, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.islamicly.com/home/screeningProcess
cryptocurrency in the light of islamic financial principles: challenges and opportunities for shariah compliance - ResearchGate, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/392407700_CRYPTOCURRENCY_IN_THE_LIGHT_OF_ISLAMIC_FINANCIAL_PRINCIPLES_CHALLENGES_AND_OPPORTUNITIES_FOR_SHARIAH_COMPLIANCE
EXAMINING THE SHARIAH COMPLIANCE OF DIGITAL ASSETS, BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY, AND DECENTRALIZED FINANCE (DeFi) WITHIN ISLAMIC FINANCIAL PRINCIPLES | CITY UNIVERSITY RESEARCH JOURNAL, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.cusitjournals.com/index.php/CURJ/article/view/1004
The legality of cryptocurrency from an Islamic perspective: a research note - IDEAS/RePEc, accessed September 1, 2025, https://ideas.repec.org/a/eme/jiabrp/jiabr-02-2022-0041.html
What is Cryptocurrency - is it halal? - Qardus, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.qardus.com/news/what-is-cryptocurrency-and-is-it-halal
Is Crypto Halal or Haram? What Different Scholars Say — Islamic ..., accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.islamicfinanceguru.com/articles/scholars-who-say-cryptocurrency-is-haram-and-those-who-say-its-halal
Is Cryptocurrency Halal? Top Islamic Finance Experts Sound Off - Sarwa, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.sarwa.co/blog/is-cryptocurrency-halal
Is Bitcoin Halal: Sharia Rules and Interpretation - Qardus, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.qardus.com/news/is-bitcoin-halal-sharia-rules-and-interpretation
Cryptocurrency Investments: A Basic and Practical Guide Following Shariah Rules - Ethis, accessed September 1, 2025, https://ethis.co/blog/cryptocurrency-investments-a-basic-and-practical-guide-following-shariah-rules/
A Critical Analysis of Cryptocurrencies from an Islamic Jurisprudence Perspective, accessed September 1, 2025, https://tujise.org/content/6-issues/15-8-1/a130/tujise-8.1-130.pdf
The Shariah factor in Cryptocurrencies and Tokens, accessed September 1, 2025, https://shariyah.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/The-Shariah-factor-in-Cryptocurrencies-and-Tokens.pdf
HAQQ Whitepaper | HAQQ - HAQQ Network, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.haqq.network/wp
What Is Halal Investing? - SmartAsset.com, accessed September 1, 2025, https://smartasset.com/investing/halal-investing
Is there an Islamic cryptocurrency? - Qardus, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.qardus.com/news/is-there-an-islamic-cryptocurrency
(PDF) Halal Cryptocurrency Model Under the Maqashid Al-Shari'ah Scheme, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/366554891_Halal_Cryptocurrency_Model_Under_the_Maqashid_Al-Shari'ah_Scheme
Islamic Coin: Empowering the Muslim Community with a Halal Digital Asset - Medium, accessed September 1, 2025, https://medium.com/@kingsleyumoh03/islamic-coin-empowering-the-muslim-community-with-a-halal-digital-asset-b0d15974e86c
Ethics-first, Shariah-compliant Crypto Engages Advisory Board, Prepares for Listing, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.entrepreneur.com/en-au/technology/ethics-first-shariah-compliant-crypto-engages-advisory/438671
Scholars - Ijara Community Development Corp., accessed September 1, 2025, https://ijaracdc.com/scholars-2/
Sharia advisor - Wikipedia, accessed September 1, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharia_advisor
Islamic Coin - Republic, accessed September 1, 2025, https://republic.com/islamic-coin
Shariah-Compliant Islamic Coin Raises $200m, Beating All Records in 2022 - CIBAFI, accessed September 1, 2025, https://cibafi.org/IndustryDetailspage?ContentID=48220
Shariah | ISLM.XYZ - Islamic Coin, accessed September 1, 2025, https://islamiccoin.net/shariah
What Is Islamic Coin ($ISLM)? Everything You Need to Know - Coins.ph, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.coins.ph/en-ph/academy/what-is-islamic-coin-islm-everything-you-need-to-know
What Is Islamic Coin (ISLM)? How Does It Work? - Bitget, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.bitget.com/academy/what-is-islamic-coin-islm-and-how-does-it-work
ISLM - Islamic Coin Price - KuCoin, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.kucoin.com/price/ISLM
Discover Islamic coin (ISLM) listing on XT.COM - Cointelegraph, accessed September 1, 2025, https://cointelegraph.com/press-releases/discover-islamic-coin-islm-listing-on-xtcom
ISLAMICOIN price today, ISLAMI to USD live price, marketcap and chart | CoinMarketCap, accessed September 1, 2025, https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/islamicoin/
ISLAMICOIN Price, ISLAMI Price, Live Charts, and Marketcap - Coinbase, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.coinbase.com/price/islamicoin
ISLAMICOIN White Paper Overview Built and ... - CryptoCompare, accessed September 1, 2025, https://resources.cryptocompare.com/asset-management/2079/1675677910175.pdf
Islamic crypto gains currency in Muslim world - TRENDS MENA, accessed September 1, 2025, https://trendsmena.com/banking-finance/islamic-crypto-gains-currency-in-muslim-world/
Onegram Sharia White Paper | PDF | Money Supply | Money - Scribd, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/document/354667365/Onegram-Sharia-White-Paper
White Paper | PDF | Fiat Money | Cryptocurrency - Scribd, accessed September 1, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/document/354667652/White-Paper
A Study of Economic Value Estimation on Cryptocurrency Value back by Gold, Methods, Techniques, and Tools - Semantic Scholar, accessed September 1, 2025, https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/8cf1/9ff406b6363df719cb8fd2e5f7d3a6f213b6.pdf